Feedback from the
Michael L. Satlow , Jewish matrimony for the antiquity. Princeton: Princeton College Drive, 2001. xii, 431 profiles ; 25 cm. ISBN 069100255X $.
Tawny Holm , Indiana College or university out of Pennsylvania.
This illuminating and comprehensive publication by Satlow happens far to display that dialogue about ong Jews, and among their Christian, Roman, and Greek neighbors, as it is today into the modern Western and you will modern Jewish people. Satlow, just who observes relationship once the good socially built, culturally mainly based facilities, offers a great refreshingly historic perspective towards alarmist discourse nowadays. “The truth the discourse regarding personal relationship ‘crisis’ can be so dated at minimum is always to aware me to this new possibility that individuals are talking about a matter of rhetoric a great deal more than just fact. xvi-xvii). Are you aware that evaluating optimistic trust one modern matrimony is rather an upgrade towards crappy old days of one’s patriarchal previous, Satlow shows that old Judaism is much more challenging than of many guess, and has now “one rabbinic articulation out of marital ideals . . . so you’re able to rival our personal egalitarian notions” (p. xvii).
Whether the “one to rabbinic articulation” from close-egalitarianism impresses every audience, Satlow’s case for great variety within different Jewish groups try well-produced (the latest Palestinian rabbis constantly come in a far greater white compared to the Babylonian), with his book often for this reason getting appealing not just to students away from Close Eastern antiquity and Judaism, but into the read personal. The analysis takes a synthetic method of Jewish wedding throughout the Mediterranean Levant (particularly Palestine) and you can Babylonia regarding the Persian several months on the rabbinic several months (ca. five-hundred B.C.Elizabeth. so you can five hundred C.Age.). You will find around three basic arguments: (1) personal Jewish sets of antiquity differed of both within their comprehension of matrimony, constantly although not always conceiving relationship regarding their historic and you may geographical context; (2) nothing is essentially Jewish in the Jewish marriage up until Jews modified lifestyle and rituals distributed to their machine communities into their own idiom so you’re able to erican marriage ceremonies now, ancient Jewish beliefs on marriage most likely diverged considerably of truth, as well as other old legal medications by rabbis shouldn’t be taken as detailed.
Satlow appropriately cautions the person towards nature of the top sources; particular episodes don’t have a lot of or skewed proof, particularly the Persian months (for which i simply have Ezra-Nehemiah from the Bible and Aramaic courtroom data files out of Egypt) plus the Babylonian Amoraic period two hundred-500 C.E. (which we do have the Babylonian Talmud, a huge supply however, one that shows a sealed rabbinic community and never Babylonian Jews at large). If not the fresh new sources and additionally consist of the brand new Palestinian Talmud and you can midrashim, Jewish blog site inside the Greek (including the Septuagint translation of kissbrides.com find your Hebrew Bible additionally the The new Testament), the fresh Lifeless Water Scrolls, scattered archaeological stays and inscriptions, and lots of sources to Jews of the non-Jewish Greek and you can Latin people.
Following the inclusion, where Satlow outlines their arguments, efforts, approach, offer, and you will methods, the ebook is actually put into around three bits. Part We, “Considering matrimony,” takes into account brand new ideology, theology, and you can judge underpinnings from relationship. Area II, “Marrying,” movements regarding the ideals out of ancient matrimony into truth, around which is it is possible to: relationships, just who y), betrothal, the wedding, plus unusual marriages (age.grams. second marriage ceremonies, polygynous marriage ceremonies, concubinage, and you may levirate marriages). Region III, “Existence Partnered,” talks about the brand new economics regarding marriage additionally the articulation out of Jewish ideals into the ancient books and you may inscriptions. Just after a final section out-of results, in which Satlow reorganizes his findings diachronically by the months and you can region, the publication closes with detailed end notes, a thorough bibliography, and you can around three indexes: topic, premodern supplies, and you may progressive people.